Is $300 a Month for SEO Legit? 8 Checks Before You Pay

"He has not changed a single letter anywhere on the website," the owner of a small moving company wrote on r/smallbusiness in February 2022. They had been paying an SEO consultant $300 a month for about six months. He had set up a Google Local Services ad, which the owner called helpful, and he sent numbers showing their traffic going up. According to the owner, he said the fee kept the business in the "internet yellow pages" and with "data base aggregators."

The post asked "Is this legit?" and drew 229 comments. The top reply in the archive we read, at 246 points, said "It sounds like you've got the right guy for your company's size." The next, at 143, said "$300 a month is cheap. Quality SEO is $1k a month for most local businesses. You get what you pay for."

We sell a plan at $300 a month, so we have a stake in the answer. We think $300 is a fair price for a small job you can name and a poor one for a job nobody can describe. The test is whether each month shows you what the money bought.

What $300 a month buys

Ahrefs polled 439 SEO providers for its pricing study, first published in December 2023. The page shows an August 2024 update and no survey date, so the rates below are at least two years old. We use it because it splits prices by type of provider.

Most common rates by provider type in Ahrefs' poll of 439 SEO providers, and the hours $300 buys at each hourly rate (our arithmetic)

Who	Monthly retainer	Per hour	$300 buys
SEO freelancer	$101 to $500, and $251 to $500	$75 to $100	3 to 4 hours
SEO agency	$500 to $1,000	$75 to $100	3 to 4 hours
SEO consultancy	$2,501 to $5,000	$100 to $150	2 to 3 hours
Elmrank	$500 first month, then $300	Not sold by the hour	See below

So $300 sits inside the freelancers' most common retainer bands and below the agencies'. It's also less common in the U.S. and Canada, where Ahrefs found that 79.1% of providers "charge at least $1,001 per month." A $300 quote pays for a few hours of work, so what matters is which hours.

In our view, 3 to 4 hours a month covers one of these well: a local business's Google Business Profile and listings kept current, a handful of fixes on existing pages, or one properly researched article. It doesn't cover all three, and it leaves no time for link building.

The r/SEO version of the question, from January 2023, shows the gap. The poster had been quoted $300 a month by several providers "Promising to do on page and off page SEO and optimizing Google my business profile." The top reply, at 18 points, came from u/PortlandWilliam: "I've been in the industry a decade and I'd be amazed if you get quality work for that price. I suppose it's possible. It's just highly unlikely." A promise that wide doesn't fit in 4 hours, though one of its three parts might.

When $300 is a fair price

The moving company is a fair example of a business $300 can serve. In an edit to the post, the owner said they had few competitors "for miles around" and already showed up "in one of the top 3 results consistently on google maps." They also found they could probably climb higher themselves "just by adding more pictures, refining the description, and fitting some of the keywords smoothly into the text of the website." A business with little competition and one channel that matters can do well on a few hours a month, as long as someone tells it what they did with them.

Listing a business with directories and data aggregators, which is what the consultant said he did, is real local SEO work. We'd expect most of it to happen once, at setup, with a check now and then afterwards. That's why we'd ask for a monthly list of listings added or corrected. Six months of the same fee with no list is the part we'd question.

$300 also makes sense when software does most of the work and a person checks it. That's how our own plan works. With a plan like that, judge the output each month, because the hours tell you little.

8 checks before you pay anyone $300 a month

These work at any price, but at $300 there's less room for waste, so we'd run all eight before the first invoice.

1. The monthly work, in numbers

"On-page and off-page SEO" isn't a deliverable. Ask for a line like "four Business Profile posts and fixes on two service pages", so you can check it at the end of the month. Two of u/PortlandWilliam's first questions for the r/SEO poster point the same way: "What kind of offpage and onpage SEO are you getting?" and "Would they be posting regularly?"

2. Changes you can see

Google's own page on hiring an SEO suggests asking: "Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site, and provide detailed information about your recommendations and the reasoning behind them?" If the answer each month is a list you can click through, you know what you paid for. The moving company's consultant hadn't changed a letter in six months, and the owner wrote that "he can't really prove to me how he makes that happen."

3. Results in your own Search Console

Ask for the report to come from your Search Console, which you can open yourself. In the moving company thread, a reply at 121 points from u/thenuttyhazlenut, who works in SEO, asked for "A report showing a list of keywords he is targeting", with each keyword's starting and current position, "once a month." Rank lists are useful, but we'd lead with clicks and impressions from Search Console, because you can check them without the provider. Our post on what a monthly SEO report should include goes line by line.

4. Every account in your name

You should own the domain, Search Console, Google Analytics and the Google Business Profile, and give the provider access. On Business Profiles, Google says "A Business Profile can have multiple owners but only one primary owner," and managers can do almost everything except "add or remove users or remove the profile." So stay the primary owner and add your provider as a manager. Google also says that for an audit you should "only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)." In the moving company thread, u/modernbetty, a web designer, at 20 points: "make sure that you have access/ownership of all services associated with your site before moving on if you choose to."

5. No ranking guarantee

Google says it plainly: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." It tells you to beware of SEOs that "claim to guarantee rankings, allege a 'special relationship' with Google, or advertise a 'priority submit' to Google." u/PortlandWilliam's version was shorter: "Watch for anyone guaranteeing SEO results. They can't." A refund promise tied to numbers in your own Search Console is a different thing from a ranking promise, and our post on SEO guarantees and refunds compares the kinds.

6. Where the links come from

If a $300 plan promises backlinks, ask for the list of links built each month. Google's spam policies list "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes" and "Low-quality directory or bookmark site links" as link spam, and its hiring page adds: "You should never have to link to an SEO." In the r/SEO thread, u/nerval, at 13 points, guessed what the backlinks in a $300 plan would be: "share a post on pinterest, add you to couple of directories and write a chat gpt blog article at best somewhere (blogspot probably) linking to you." (The poster replied that the providers had named Ahrefs and Semrush as their tools.) We'd rather pay for no links than for those.

7. Who writes the articles, and who checks them

If articles are part of a $300 plan, ask who drafts them and who reads them before they go live. At 3 to 4 hours a month, more than one hand-written article is unlikely, so a plan with several is probably drafting with AI, as ours does. Google doesn't object to that as such. It warns that using generative AI "to generate many pages without adding value for users may violate" its scaled content abuse policy, and says "It is critical to manually factcheck and review all AI-generated content for accuracy and trustworthiness before publishing." The answer you want is the name of the person who checks.

8. How you leave

Ask how long the contract runs, how much notice you need to give, and what stays with you when you stop. u/PortlandWilliam: "Watch for long-term contracts because they take away some of your control." The moving company's owner asked whether cancelling would cost them traffic. In a reply to the post, u/modernbetty wrote that "Ending the relationship SHOULD NOT equal a drop in traffic or rankings unless he's doing shady work or disconnects your sites from Google services." Our post on how to fire your SEO agency covers the handover.

• What exactly will you do each month, in numbers?
• Will you list every change you make, with links?
• Will the report come from my own Search Console?
• Will I stay the owner of the domain, Search Console, Analytics and Business Profile?
• Do you promise any ranking? (The right answer is no.)
• Which links will you build, and where from?
• Who writes the articles, and who checks them before they go live?
• How long is the contract, what notice do you need, and what stays with me?

Where our $300 fits

Here's our plan against the same eight checks. The first month is $500 and covers an SEO and GEO audit, the technical fixes it finds (speed, indexing, schema and site structure), site design and a content plan. From the second month it's $300 a month for up to 30 articles, ongoing technical fixes, hosting, the domain and a monthly report.

1. The number of articles depends on your niche and needs, up to 30 a month, and the monthly report lists each one.
2. The same report lists what we fixed.
3. Results are your Search Console clicks and impressions; our sample report is filled in with one of our own sites.
4. The domain is registered in your name, and when you cancel we transfer it to your account at no charge.
5. We don't promise rankings. Our terms promise a refund if your Google clicks haven't grown after 6 paid months in a row, compared with your first month, with conditions listed there.
6. The plan doesn't include link building, and our terms say so.
7. Our pipeline researches, drafts and fact-checks the articles with AI, and a person approves each one before it's published.
8. There's no minimum contract. You can cancel any time by email, and it takes effect at the end of the month you've paid for.

What $300 doesn't buy from us: link building, Google Business Profile posts, review replies, ads or meetings. If links or your Maps listing are what you're missing, a local SEO freelancer at the same price is the better fit. Elmrank is the trading name of one person based in Vietnam, and we reply to email within 12 hours. Our SEO content service page lists what each month includes, and if you're still working out a budget, how much SEO costs per month covers the full range.

How we know this

Written by Tyler Phan. Every source below was read on the date shown; the page was last reviewed on Oct 22, 2026.

1. r/smallbusiness, SEO consultant charging family business $300/month. Is this legit? (post and replies by u/Stecki_fangaz; comments by u/wuh_happon, u/Sachimarketing, u/thenuttyhazlenut, u/modernbetty), accessed Oct 20, 2026
2. r/SEO, $300 USD/Month for Local SEO good price for good quality or no? (post and reply by u/Goku560; comments by u/PortlandWilliam and u/nerval), accessed Oct 20, 2026
3. Ahrefs, SEO Pricing: How Much Does SEO Cost? 439 People Polled (first published Dec 2023, updated Aug 2024), accessed Oct 20, 2026
4. Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO?, accessed Oct 20, 2026
5. Google Search Central, Spam policies for Google web search (link spam, scaled content abuse), accessed Oct 20, 2026
6. Google Search Central, Google Search's guidance on using generative AI content on your website, accessed Oct 20, 2026
7. Google Business Profile Help, Manage your Business Profile owners & managers, accessed Oct 20, 2026
8. Elmrank, Terms of Service, accessed Oct 20, 2026
9. Elmrank, Pricing, accessed Oct 20, 2026

Send us your site.

We reply within 12 hours with what we'd fix first. Then we run it for you, technical SEO and content: $500 for the first month, then $300 a month for up to 30 articles. You don't need any technical knowledge, and you can cancel any time.

Get my free first-fix listSee what's included